Where and How to Sell Used Video Games in Good Condition

If you have old titles collecting dust, now may be the perfect time to sell video games—especially if they’re in good condition. Whether it’s vintage NES cartridges or recent PlayStation hits, used games hold strong resale value when handled properly. The key to getting a good deal is knowing where and how to sell them.

Start by cleaning your games and checking for damage. Scratched discs, missing cases, or non-working cartridges will reduce their value significantly. Games in their original cases with intact cover art and manuals often sell for more, particularly if they’re part of a collector’s set.

You can sell online through platforms like eBay or Facebook Marketplace, or choose a local option for faster transactions. A smart choice for sellers in Illinois is the Comic Buying Center in Libertyville. Known for purchasing retro and modern games alike, they offer in-person evaluations and fair cash offers without the hassle of shipping.

Whether you’re selling a single title or a whole collection, presenting your games clean, complete, and organized increases your chances of a better payout. Working with reputable buyers also ensures your items are priced accurately and handled with care.

What Affects the Resale Value of Old Video Games

Several factors influence the resale value of used video games, and knowing what buyers look for can help you get a better return. Condition is the top consideration. Games that include their original cases, manuals, and cover art are more desirable, especially for collectors. Discs or cartridges should be clean and functional—any visible damage can significantly reduce value.

Rarity is another big factor. Limited-edition releases, games with low production runs, or titles that were only released in specific regions often command higher prices. For example, rare titles from consoles like the Sega Saturn or TurboGrafx-16 can be far more valuable than common Xbox or PlayStation releases.

Demand plays a role too. Popular franchises like Zelda, Final Fantasy, or Mario tend to retain their value better than lesser-known titles. Older games that have seen remakes or sparked nostalgic interest often see renewed demand.

Finally, the platform matters. Cartridge-based games tend to hold value better over time, while some disc-based games lose value quickly unless they’re rare or in high demand. For those unsure where their collection stands, places like the Comic Buying Center in Libertyville can provide fast, accurate appraisals.

Should You Sell Online or Locally? Pros and Cons

Deciding whether to sell video games online or locally depends on your priorities—speed, profit, and convenience. Online selling offers a wider audience and the potential for higher prices, especially for rare or in-demand titles. Platforms like eBay and Mercari let you set your own prices and reach collectors across the country. However, selling online also means dealing with shipping, platform fees, potential returns, and time-consuming listings.

Selling locally—through game stores, collectors, or buyback centers—can be much faster. You typically receive a cash offer on the spot, with no waiting or shipping involved. Local buyers like the Comic Buying Center in Libertyville specialize in evaluating used video games and often give fair market prices, especially if your items are in good condition and complete.

The downside to local selling is that you may earn slightly less than you would through a bidding war online. However, for many sellers, the speed, simplicity, and personal interaction make up for it.

In the end, if you want the highest price and have time to wait, online might be the way to go. But if you’re looking for convenience and a quick payout, local selling is often the smarter choice.